In conversation | BNG from the developer's side

For housebuilders, biodiversity net gain (BNG) is now part of the everyday reality of development. But what does delivering it actually look like, beyond the regulations and the metric?

We caught up with Dan Massie, Development Director at The Hill Group, one of the UK's leading privately owned housebuilders, to hear how BNG is playing out from the developer's side of the table. We talked about its place in Hill's wider business strategy, the decisions behind on-site and off-site delivery, lessons learnt along the way and what makes a good BNG partner.

Where does BNG sit within Hill’s wider business strategy?

For us, it's part of something much bigger than a planning requirement. Placemaking and social value are central to what we do at Hill. We're creating places where people will live for generations, so the environment around those homes really matters.

BNG has brought more structure to how we approach biodiversity, but the thinking behind it isn't new to us. We take responsibility for the long-term impact of what we build by creating sustainable places to live and contributing positively to local communities.

How has BNG changed the way you approach development?

I think the biggest thing is making sure we're considering it early enough.

BNG needs to be part of the conversation from land acquisition onwards, through feasibility, master-planning, and design. Understanding the requirements from the outset means you have more options and can make better-informed decisions.

It also involves people from across the business. Ecologists bring essential technical expertise, but our development, land, planning and design teams all have a role to play. Getting those conversations going early makes a real difference.

How do you decide between on-site and off-site BNG?

There's no one-size-fits-all answer. We consider both and weigh up what makes sense for each development.

On-site BNG can help create attractive, greener neighbourhoods, but we also need to balance the needs of residents with those of nature, while thinking about the long-term management and maintenance costs of different habitats.

Off-site BNG gives us another option. We can support habitat creation and restoration locally, with benefits that extend beyond the development boundary to the wider community.

Ultimately, there's a commercial decision to make. It's about balancing ecological outcomes, the needs of residents, and what makes sense for the development.

When you need an off-site solution, what matters most?

Location is our starting point. We want to understand where the biodiversity gains will be delivered and how they connect to the communities in which we're building. Keeping those benefits local is important to us.

Price matters, of course, but credibility and integrity are critical. Can the provider genuinely deliver what they're promising? Do they have the ecological expertise, financial security and long-term commitment to manage those habitats for the next 30 years?

With housebuilding activity subdued, the market for off-site BNG units is competitive, and we're seeing some keen pricing. It'll be interesting to see how that changes as the housing market recovers and demand picks up.

Whatever the market conditions, though, you need to look beyond the price tag. It's about finding the right location and a partner you can trust to deliver what they've committed to, not simply the cheapest.

What has surprised you about delivering BNG in practice?

Some of the things we thought might be challenging have actually been more straightforward than expected.

Brownfield developments are a good example. We initially anticipated that meeting BNG requirements on these sites could be difficult, but that hasn't necessarily been our experience.

The planning process itself can be slow, but BNG hasn't been the reason for those delays. We've never had a development stalled because of BNG, and it hasn't prevented us from progressing a land acquisition either.

That's not to say there aren't things to work through. Every development is different, but our experience has been that BNG is something you can plan for and deliver alongside the other considerations that come with development.

What has stood out to you about Biofarm’s approach?

Biofarm stood out against the criteria we look for in an off-site provider, particularly around location, ecological credibility and confidence in delivery.

There's a personal element too. Hill is a family-run and privately-owned business, as is Biofarm, and I think there's a shared sense of investment in what we do and the relationships we build.

What I've appreciated is their openness. They're always willing to have a conversation, explore an idea or offer a view, even when it might not lead to us working together on a particular development.

That makes a difference. Having people you can pick up the phone to, talk things through with and get a considered answer from is valuable.

What do you think comes next for BNG?

I think the next really interesting phase will be understanding what BNG looks like once habitats are under management.

We've spent a lot of time as an industry getting to grips with the regulations, the metrics, and how to deliver biodiversity gains. But nature takes time. We're not going to have all the answers after a year or two.

It will take time to build up meaningful data, understand how habitats are developing and see what the management approaches are actually achieving.

That's when we'll start to learn much more about what works, what doesn't and where we can improve.

Ultimately, the next chapter is about understanding what those commitments are delivering in practice, not just what was agreed at the beginning.

Previous
Previous

Habitat restoration progresses at Lesnewth Habitat Bank in Cornwall

Next
Next

A new chapter for infrastructure BNG